I am sometimes bothered by people’s tendency to reflect on the past and on people from history and assuming that those people should have had the moral outlook of today. Mostly, this process results in a very negative view of those that lived a long time ago and I don’t think that outlook is reasonable. Most people are a product of their time and environment. It is really hard to say that they should have known better. Mostly though, it makes me worried for myself and what the future might think of me. Is there some sort of societal norm that I am following now that the world will think is reprehensible 100-200 years in the future. Will they look back on today and find that everyone now was a bigoted monster? Below are the main examples I can think of for what people view the history negatively on and a couple ideas on what nowadays people may be viewed negatively on in the future.
Disclaimer: I am not against looking back at the past and saying they were wrong. I am against looking back at the past and insulting or denigrating them from stupid beliefs that were reasonable at the time.
Past was wrong: Slavery
Yes, slavery is bad. People have been writing about the evils of slavery for a long time. Even Thomas Jefferson said that slavery was a blight on the country despite himself owning slaves and only freeing a few of the ones he owned. As far as I can tell, the uneducated didn’t realize it was a bad thing. They either thought it was normal, the slaves we not the same as free-folk, or just didn’t concern themselves with it. Educated people thought that slaves were mentally inferior and that they would not be able to function properly in society if they were released (keeping them slaves was what was keeping them alive!!).
Past was wrong: Women’s Rights
There was no birth control. Sexually active women had kids every 1-2 years and they were needed to feed those kids. when 90%+ of women are stuck with the kids and have little ability to have major careers, then it is men who are in almost every leadership position. Those men were the heads of every company, military organization, political organization, etc. The men of 100s of years ago looked around and saw that men were the educated elites. Therefore, by saying that only men can vote/hold office/etc., society makes sure that only educated elites were the ones in power. If by some bizarre twist of biology, men had to stay home to care for the kids (women had babies, but men breastfed or something), then I would expect the educated elite women to have said that only women can vote/etc. Men keeping women out of power was because men looked around, saw men in power, and thought that it was some property of being a man that made them better able to vote/hold office/etc.
Past was wrong: LGBT+
People were much more religious in the past and the bible straight out says that homosexuality is wrong. As many homosexual/bisexual/transgendered/etc. people existed in the past as did today. However, they had to hide or pretend to be straight. Since those people were hiding, each hiding person thought they were the unique devil tempted individual and the ones that acted on it were impure souls that could resist temptation. It is hard to impress how much direct literal information people of the past believed from the bible (example: historians expected to find evidence of a worldwide flood). When everyone’s main source of information says something is wrong and evil, it is hard to not believe that that thing is wrong and evil. Judging historical people for believing their main info source is like judging a North Korean citizen for thinking the DPRK is a bastion of peace and freedom and that the rest of the world is evil.
Present might be wrong: Animal Rights
I sometimes wonder if the humanity will eventually go vegetarian. Animal feel pain and we inflict pain on them when we kill them for food. I am generally against hunting and fishing unless it is for food, but I can imagine a future where the feelings (especially pain) of other creatures has gotten the same level of respect as the feelings of humans. Can you imagine what those people would think of you non-vegetarians who eat meat regularly or even the vegetarians who through inaction allow millions of animals to suffer and die every day?
Present might be wrong: Sibling Marriage
This is the thought that prompted this post. I have a flag outside my house that has several platitudes on it, one of which is “Love is Love”. On the walk to school I was explaining it to my kids as LGBT rights and that it is okay for men and men to marry or women and women to marry. My 6 year old son then said, “So some day I can marry my sister?”, to which I said no because there are laws against it. As I said it, I was thinking about why those laws are on the books and that it might actually be possible for someone to fall in love with their sibling. I have a major cringe factor to the idea of my kids marrying each other, but I recognize that this is one area where the people of the future might look back and see that it is okay.
Questions for anyone reading this: What moral ideas might we be wrong about today that future generations will judge us on?